Overview
Ratings at a glance
SuperiorsPeersDirect Reports1–10 scale
Communication
Employee and Organization Development
Execution
Leadership
Managing Up
Managing Workload
Strategy and Long-term Thinking
Teamwork and Collaboration
Overview
Executive Summary
Susan Smith is viewed by her stakeholders as a highly capable and technically proficient product leader who has made significant contributions to the organization, yet faces critical challenges in transitioning from individual contributor excellence to strategic leadership effectiveness. Stakeholders consistently praise her technical depth, execution capabilities, and commitment to delivering quality products, with one describing her as "one of the rock stars at the company" and noting her transformation of a "completely dysfunctional" machine learning team into a well-functioning unit.
Her execution strengths are widely recognized across the organization. Stakeholders describe her as the "best executor among all product managers" with exceptional personal delivery capabilities and a "do whatever it takes" attitude. She demonstrates strong data-driven decision-making, thorough research capabilities, and reliable follow-through on commitments. Her technical knowledge enables effective collaboration with engineering teams, and she has successfully deployed technology across one-third of the customer base while maintaining high standards for product quality.
However, stakeholders identify a fundamental tension between Susan's operational excellence and the strategic thinking required at her level. Multiple interviews reveal concerns about her focus on immediate work completion rather than long-term organizational planning and process improvement. One stakeholder noted she tends to get "bogged down in immediate technical problems rather than taking a 3-5 year vision perspective," while another emphasized the need for her to be "6 months ahead of engineering team in terms of market and customer research" rather than her current 2 weeks to 1 month timeframe.
Communication presents a complex picture of strengths and development needs. While stakeholders praise her ability to communicate effectively with senior leadership and her strong writing skills, they identify significant inefficiencies in her written communications. Feedback indicates she produces lengthy, overly detailed documents when simple updates are requested, with one stakeholder noting "we really just needed a paragraph and you probably spent like, I don't know how long writing two pages." Additionally, there are concerns about her transparency across the organization, with limited visibility into her full scope of work and impact.
Average of all 14 raters · Theme 1 of 8
Communication
The stakeholder interviews reveal a complex picture of Susan Smith's communication capabilities. While she demonstrates strong verbal communication skills and excels at communicating with leadership, there are significant opportunities for improvement in written communication efficiency, cross-functional transparency, and adapting her communication style to diverse audiences.
Susan Smith's top strength lies in her ability to communicate effectively with senior leadership. She understands how to address executives with the appropriate style and demonstrates strong stakeholder management skills at the leadership level. Her recent company offsite presentations were well-received, with one stakeholder noting she was "well prepared, very well spoken, and very data driven."
Stakeholders consistently praise Susan Smith's directness and articulation. She provides clear feedback and doesn't leave people guessing about her perspective. Her verbal communication is described as strong, well-spoken, and structured, with stakeholders appreciating that she doesn't appear guarded or overly diplomatic.
Stakeholder Recommendations
- Develop Communication Efficiency Skills - Susan should focus on creating concise, targeted communications that match audience needs. This includes developing templates and frameworks for common communication types and practicing the skill of distilling complex information into key takeaways.
- Increase Transparency and Visibility - Implement regular communication channels that provide visibility into Susan's broader impact and contributions. This could include brief weekly updates to key stakeholders highlighting her involvement in cross-functional issues and conflicts.
- Practice Audience Adaptation - Develop skills in assessing audience needs and adapting communication style accordingly. This includes using simpler language for diverse teams, providing multiple levels of detail (executive summary plus deep dive options), and considering cultural and linguistic diversity.
- Balance Preparation with Authenticity - While preparation is valuable, Susan should work on maintaining authenticity in her delivery, particularly during difficult conversations. This might involve practicing more natural delivery styles and being more transparent about challenging situations rather than over-scripting responses.
- Prioritize Strategic Communication - Allocate more time and energy to upward and outward communication, recognizing this as a critical component of her senior role rather than a burden. This includes proactive stakeholder updates and customer-facing communication opportunities.
Average of all 14 raters · Theme 2 of 8
Employee and Organization Development
Stakeholders gave Susan Smith a rating of 7.5 in the area of Employee and Organization Development.
Senior leadership observed that Susan may not be providing sufficient coaching to her team members, noting alignment on work products but less focus on developing team execution capabilities. There was a suggestion to learn from seasoned engineering leaders who have strong people management experience.
Recommendations emerged for Susan to expand her professional network and connect with other product managers outside the organization, emphasizing the value of having a group of peers to bounce ideas off of beyond formal coaching relationships. Leadership offered to facilitate connections through their network.
Stakeholder Recommendations
- Learn from seasoned engineering leaders who have strong people management experience to develop coaching capabilities and focus more on developing team execution capabilities rather than just aligning on work products
- Expand professional network by connecting with other product managers outside the organization to have a group of peers to bounce ideas off of and explore how other companies approach product management challenges
- Implement regular "How am I doing?" meetings focused on performance and job satisfaction rather than project updates, and utilize management training tools and frameworks to create a feedback culture where all levels welcome and listen to feedback
- Adapt management approach for different experience levels, particularly learning how to manage team members who may have more expertise in specific areas while maintaining a questioning approach rather than giving direct instructions
- Shift from past organizational dysfunction focus to future-oriented thinking and move from early-stage startup "roll up your sleeves" mentality to more strategic leadership approach as the paradigm shift in worldview will be key to unlocking next level of performance
Average of all 14 raters · Theme 3 of 8
Execution
Susan Smith demonstrates exceptional technical depth as a product manager, successfully participating in and contributing to technical conversations with engineering teams despite lacking formal technical education background. She shows genuine commitment to building amazing products rather than focusing on political advancement and exhibits strong judgment in prioritizing the right initiatives within given timeframes.
She excels at traditional product management execution including product launches, go-to-market coordination, and customer engagement. Her highly data-driven approach consistently requests specific examples and data to support decisions, backed by eight years of industry experience in established product management processes.
Susan consistently delivers structured, researched, and data-driven work products with high reliability and willingness to roll up sleeves and complete work directly. She is highly action-driven and detail-oriented with excellent personal execution capabilities, showing strong follow-through on plans and commitments with careful attention to completion.
Stakeholder Recommendations
- Transition from personal execution to delegation and team enablement - Susan needs to release control and trust others to execute, accepting imperfect outcomes from team members rather than doing work personally
- Develop clearer pathways from idea to finished product implementation with more organized execution approach from a product management perspective
- Adopt a more "scrappy" startup mindset for key differentiating features to reduce lengthy development cycles and meet competitive market speed requirements
- Improve visibility and communication about broader execution plans and responsibilities to ensure cross-functional teams have clear understanding of execution coordination
- Focus on core product management responsibilities rather than over-involvement in execution details that prevent attention to essential duties
Average of all 14 raters · Theme 4 of 8
Leadership
Susan operates with high independence, which raises questions about the leadership guidance she provides to her team. There's uncertainty about whether she functions more as an independent operator versus a collaborative leader, with concerns about her ability to scale from managing individuals to organizing groups of teams.
A significant leadership opportunity exists with a colleague going on leave, creating a vacuum Susan could fill. However, stakeholders emphasize that even small teams require strong management, noting "when those people make mistakes, like we get screwed." There's an expectation that Susan needs to prepare for leading at a higher organizational level as the company grows.
Susan demonstrates strong performance under pressure, described as "pretty calm under pressure" and able to work through challenging situations effectively. However, she faces challenges with trusting engineering managers and delegation. Limited visibility exists into her direct report leadership capabilities, with concerns about her relationship with the delivery organization.
Stakeholder Recommendations
- Transition from micromanagement to high-leverage leadership tasks by delegating more individual contributor work and stepping back from detailed engineering decisions to focus on high-level product vision and goals
- Develop team members independently rather than shielding them from challenges - move from viewing difficulties as "burden to shield" to "opportunity to prioritize" and allow learning opportunities instead of throwing her body in front of every challenge
- Scale leadership capabilities from managing individuals to organizing groups of teams, preparing for higher organizational level leadership as the company grows beyond small team management
- Improve inspirational leadership qualities by guiding people to discover answers independently rather than providing direct solutions, moving beyond just influencing to truly inspiring others
- Expand focus beyond immediate team to engage proactively with other stakeholders and business areas, sharing product vision company-wide and gathering input from various teams
Average of all 14 raters · Theme 5 of 8
Managing Up
Senior leadership values Susan Smith's transparency and appreciates that she doesn't try to hide problems or manage her manager by concealing issues. However, there's a significant concern regarding her approach to resource management and prioritization. Susan tends to take on excessive workload rather than appropriately pushing back or requesting additional resources. There's a pattern of her trying to power through and muscle through challenges instead of addressing systemic problems. She rarely voices concerns about inadequate processes or underperforming team members, instead choosing to absorb and deal with issues herself. With only a two-month runway before key personnel transition out, there's urgency around coaching Susan to shift from a reactive to a more strategic approach in managing up.
Peer leadership highlights concerns about Susan's communication regarding team dependencies and strategic alignment. Susan, along with the broader team, isn't effectively managing up on dependency issues, particularly around project allocation across multiple teams. A specific example involves uncertainty about whether one team should handle a project entirely or split it among three teams. Susan appears really nervous about managing up to the CEO, especially as the product team assumes increased responsibility for engineering management functions. There are questions about whether effective upward management to senior leadership is even feasible given current structural constraints.
Susan demonstrates defensive tendencies when managing up. During a recent offsite discussion involving the CEO and other leaders on a technical topic, Susan's responses to CEO suggestions consistently came across as couched and defensive rather than collaborative exploration of ideas. Even when receiving input from someone with extensive experience in their space, Susan's approach lacks openness to alternative perspectives. Regarding feedback-seeking behavior, Susan demonstrates good initiative in asking for input every two to three sessions, but could improve by making requests more specific and contextual rather than general. She should reference specific interactions or launches when seeking feedback rather than asking broad questions about improvement areas.
Stakeholder Recommendations
- Develop proactive communication by establishing regular status updates to senior leadership and adopting a CEO perspective when determining what information to share upward, focusing on what leadership needs to know rather than what you want to tell them
- Create and actively communicate a clear one-year product vision to leadership to shift from reactive response to proactive strategic communication, helping leadership gain confidence in your direction rather than receiving ad hoc requests
- Practice appropriate pushback by requesting additional resources when needed and voicing concerns about inadequate processes or underperforming team members instead of trying to power through systemic problems alone
- Improve openness during leadership discussions by replacing defensive responses with collaborative exploration of ideas, especially when receiving input from experienced leadership
- Enhance advocacy skills by demonstrating stronger support for team members during compensation discussions and other situations requiring managerial backing
Average of all 14 raters · Theme 6 of 8
Managing Workload
Multiple stakeholders consistently identified Susan Smith's tendency to take on excessive responsibilities, particularly in engineering tasks where her technical depth becomes both an asset and a liability. One stakeholder noted she's "being a bit too much of a hero picking up slack on the engineering team itself" and emphasized the need to "stop being the hero." This pattern appears to stem from both situational demands and potentially ingrained behavioral tendencies.
The organization acknowledges significant under-resourcing across Susan Smith's areas of responsibility. With 25 hours of meetings per week and being pulled into individual contributor work, Susan Smith is managing multiple product areas (ML product, omni-channel product) while also managing team members. Stakeholders recognize the team is "definitely not adequately resourced" even with planned hiring initiatives.
Several stakeholders observed Susan Smith's reluctance to delegate effectively, even when capable team members are available. One engineering manager reported that during Susan Smith's vacation, the team successfully handled all tickets and management tasks, yet upon her return, she resumed hands-on involvement despite being told it wasn't necessary. This suggests difficulty in trusting others to maintain standards and fear of accountability for deliverables managed by her reports.
Stakeholder Recommendations
- Radically change time allocation by dropping day-to-day engineering team involvement and establishing clear boundaries around reactive, technical work that doesn't require director-level involvement
- Implement "ruthless prioritization" with explicit trade-off conversations with leadership, focusing on 1-2 major initiatives rather than spreading attention across numerous concurrent projects
- Practice saying no to additional responsibilities and requests, while initiating proactive conversations with leadership about capacity constraints and trade-offs
- Leverage incoming hires (ML product manager and omni-channel product manager) to remove entire areas from Susan Smith's plate and delegate more effectively to capable team members
- Run experimental periods (2-4 weeks) of ideal time allocation to identify what actually breaks versus what doesn't, accepting that some deliverables may be completed at 80% rather than 100% of personal standards
Average of all 14 raters · Theme 7 of 8
Strategy and Long-term Thinking
Stakeholders gave Susan Smith a rating of 7.3 in the area of Strategy and Long-term Thinking.
Stakeholders consistently identified a significant gap between Susan Smith's operational focus and the strategic thinking required for her role. Multiple interviews revealed that Susan concentrates heavily on immediate work completion rather than improving organizational processes and systems. She tends to get bogged down in day-to-day operational details and immediate technical problems, rather than engaging in the higher-level, longer-range thinking necessary for effective strategic leadership.
The feedback highlighted Susan's strong execution capabilities, particularly with product launches like the FAQ/Gen AI initiative, where she demonstrated excellent go-to-market approach and customer experimentation planning. However, stakeholders emphasized a critical distinction between execution strategy, which Susan excels at, and higher-level strategic thinking about whether projects should be undertaken at all. Her research strengths and thoroughness in competitive analysis were praised, but these capabilities haven't translated into forward-thinking product strategy.
Stakeholder Recommendations
- Focus more on "how you're doing the work" rather than just completing the work itself, with greater emphasis on organizational planning and process improvement to build the necessary organizational sophistication for the scale of operations.
- Develop transparent decision-making processes including systematic evaluation methods like RICE scoring for prioritizing initiatives, and clearly communicate what projects are NOT being pursued as part of strategic planning.
- Work backwards from a 3-5 year product vision to identify necessary interim steps, rather than getting bogged down in immediate technical problems, and engage the leadership team more proactively with strategic options and direction-setting discussions.
- Challenge the established way of doing things rather than defaulting to existing processes, and become more comfortable with strategic risks and potential failures that could unlock future opportunities through experimentation and learning.
- Reallocate time to be 6 months ahead of the engineering team in terms of market and customer research instead of the current 2 weeks to 1 month, focusing on structured customer research and data-driven strategy development.
Average of all 14 raters · Theme 8 of 8
Teamwork and Collaboration
Stakeholders gave Susan Smith a rating of 6.3 in the area of Teamwork and Collaboration.
Susan Smith demonstrates strong commitment to team support and maintains a "roll up sleeves and get in there" mentality. She exhibits technical depth and expertise that benefits team dynamics, particularly within her immediate product team where she maintains positive collaborative relationships. She is described as even-keeled, doesn't get flustered, and maintains excellent collaborative relationships with many company stakeholders across the organization.
However, Susan may be overly accommodating, with feedback suggesting she should stop taking on excessive responsibility. There is limited visibility into her collaboration with senior leadership, with stakeholders noting uncertainty about whether she is being appropriately assertive given her experience level.
Stakeholder Recommendations
- Gather feedback and input earlier in processes rather than seeking collaboration primarily at latter stages, and involve more people in the process rather than just delivering outputs
- Invest more time in relationship-building with cross-functional teams, particularly delivery and engineering teams, moving beyond transactional interactions to build trust and psychological safety
- Adopt a more programmatic approach to client-facing collaboration and increase systematic engagement with cross-functional teams rather than relying on one-off interactions
- Develop better balance between respecting others' roles and optimizing for higher-level organizational goals, avoiding being overly respectful of boundaries to the point of organizational inefficiency
- Reduce professional distance and strong "work face" to facilitate informal relationship building, which helps collaboration effectiveness especially when needing help from engineers
Conclusion
Concluding Summary
Susan Smith emerges from stakeholder feedback as a highly capable but complex executive whose strengths in execution and technical depth are counterbalanced by significant challenges in strategic leadership and collaboration. Stakeholders consistently recognize her as one of the organization's "rock stars," with exceptional personal execution capabilities that have driven substantial impact across the company. Her ability to deliver structured, data-driven work products and her willingness to "roll up sleeves" during critical periods has earned widespread respect, particularly from senior leadership who value her direct communication style and reliability.
However, a critical pattern emerges around Susan's struggle to transition from individual contributor excellence to strategic leadership. Multiple stakeholders express concern about her tendency to take on excessive responsibilities, particularly in engineering tasks where she becomes "too much of a hero picking up slack." This over-involvement prevents her from operating at the appropriate strategic level, with one stakeholder noting she spends "zero time on longer range vision strategy stuff" due to operational demands. The consensus is that Susan needs to delegate more effectively and trust others to execute, even if outcomes aren't perfect, to scale her impact and focus on director-level responsibilities.
Communication presents a nuanced challenge for Susan. While stakeholders praise her verbal communication skills with senior leadership and her exceptional writing ability, significant gaps exist in cross-functional transparency and efficiency. Her tendency toward verbose, overly detailed written communication creates inefficiency, with stakeholders requesting simple updates but receiving lengthy documents that don't match audience needs. Additionally, her use of complex terminology sometimes excludes non-native speakers and creates accessibility barriers for diverse teams. The feedback suggests Susan struggles to adapt her communication style to different audiences and contexts.
Next steps
Your Action Plan
Question 1
What's your priority?The things the feedback says are worth working on, in your words.Question 2
What does success look like?What people would see you doing differently when it's working.